Corporate Law and Litigation

How to explain to the judge that a DAO cannot be sued

Cómo explicarle al juez que una DAO no puede ser demandada

The rise of DAOs (decentralised autonomous organisations) has posed interesting challenges to the traditional legal framework. In a legal system built on the legal personality of entities such as companies, the arrival of decentralised models that operate through smart contracts and blockchain protocols has sparked considerable debate about their liability and their capacity to be sued.

The case at hand, that of Lido DAO, illustrates the problem perfectly. A California judge has to decide whether an LLC (limited liability company) designated by a DAO can appear in court proceedings as the DAO’s representative, or whether the claim should be dismissed because the decentralised organisation lacks legal capacity. What is at stake, in essence, is whether a DAO can be treated as a general partnership and, therefore, be sued in jurisdictions where legal liability is attributed to it.

The legal personality of DAOs: a disputed fiction:
The general theory of companies allows the law to grant legal personality to entities that are, in essence, groups of people joining forces in pursuit of a common goal. This legal fiction has been a fundamental pillar in the development of the modern economy, allowing partnerships and corporations to act as a single unit before the law. In the case of DAOs, however, the very structure of these organisations clashes with this traditional notion.

In the more than five years I have spent studying DAOs, I continue to be struck by the number of challenges they pose to the legal system. This case, in particular, highlights how difficult it is to fit a DAO into existing legal categories. Lido DAO, a DeFi (decentralised finance) platform, allows users to take part in Ethereum staking without having to lock up their ETH. On 3 April 2024, a class action was filed against Lido DAO, describing it as a “general partnership” operating in the Ethereum staking business and alleging that LDO tokens are securities that the DAO unlawfully offers to the public.

The DAO’s procedural strategy: a legal paradox:
So far, the legal dispute does not seem out of the ordinary. Several lawsuits have been brought against DAOs over the years, with mixed results. What is truly fascinating about this case is the procedural strategy Lido DAO has adopted in its defence. Rather than appearing before the court as a party, the DAO takes a “denial of capacity” stance. In other words, it argues that a DAO, because of its decentralised nature and its existence as software code, cannot be sued because it has no legal personality.

This defence raises a fundamental paradox: how can a DAO claim that it lacks the legal capacity to be sued while at the same time taking part in the proceedings through an LLC designated as its representative? This contradiction is precisely what is at issue in this case, and it could set an important precedent for the legal future of DAOs.

Lido DAO has appointed Dolphin CL LLC to appear in court and file a motion to dismiss the claim on the ground of “lack of capacity to be sued”. However, this LLC does not act as an attorney-in-fact or formal representative of the DAO. In fact, Lido’s own decision expressly states that Dolphin CL LLC has no legal authority over the DAO and does not officially represent its interests.

A comparative approach, SPAIN: how would other jurisdictions react?
At this point, it is worth considering how a court in another jurisdiction, such as Spain, might deal with a similar case. Imagine, for example, a Spanish judge at a preliminary hearing in a lawsuit against a DAO. What would happen if an agent appointed by the DAO for that single purpose appeared to argue that “software cannot be sued”?

This situation would challenge the judge’s conventional understanding: accustomed to dealing with traditional legal entities, the judge might struggle to understand how an organisation that actively participates in the economy, carries out transactions and manages assets in a decentralised way can maintain that it bears no legal liability. It would be interesting to see whether the Spanish courts would take an approach similar to California’s, or follow other criteria, perhaps influenced by the European legal framework.

Final reflections and angles to explore:
This case raises many interesting questions, from the application of the in pari delicto doctrine to the legal nature of the tokens and of the transactions carried out by DAOs. The plaintiff in this case is a token holder, which adds a further layer of complexity to the dispute. To what extent can a token holder be considered an interested party in a lawsuit against a DAO? And, more importantly, how does this relationship affect the analysis of the DAO’s legal liability?

Finally, it is worth noting that this case will affect not only Lido DAO but will set a precedent for every DAO operating in the DeFi ecosystem. Its outcome could determine how DAOs are viewed by the courts in future, and whether they will have to adapt to new rules governing their operations or will continue to operate on the margins of the traditional legal system.

Newsletter

Strategic insights in your inbox

Regulatory analysis and case notes from the jurisdictions where we work. You can unsubscribe at any time.